Our Pies


Our amazing pies are handmade everyday in every one of our shops. Fresh flavors explode in your mouth as you savor this truly luxurious delicacy. We bake over 40 fruit and cream pies that taste as good as they look, choose from 6” and 9” or individual slices. Call your local pie shop to see what we’re baking today.

Cherry

Featuring Northern Michigan Montmorency Tart Cherries.

  • Old Mission Cherry
  • Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb
  • Cherry Peach Crumb
  • Long Lake Cherry Berry
  • Orchard Natural Cherry
  • Splenda Cherry
  • Cherry Apple Crumb
  • Cherry Rhubarb

Buy Pies >

Apple

Made with Northern Michigan Spy Apples, the undisputed best!

  • Front Street Apple
  • Peninsula Apple Crumb
  • Gill’s Pier Apple Dumpling
  • Apple Dumpling with Caramel Topping
  • East Bay Natural Apple
  • Splenda Apple
  • ABC and ABC Crumb (Michigan apples, blueberries, and cherries)

Buy Pies >

Blueberry

Berries from Northern Michigan – naturally sweet globes of goodness!

  • Suttons Bay Blueberry
  • Opera House Blueberry Peach
  • West Bay Blueberry Crumb
  • Splenda Blueberry

Buy Pies >

Lemon Meringue

The classic that Grandma was famous for!

Peach

Savor this golden, rosy-blushed sweet and nutritious fruit in your pie!

Buy Pies >

  • Farmer’s Market Peach
  • Glen Haven Peach Crumb
  • Union Street Peach Strawberry
  • Blackberry Peach Crumb

Berry

Only the freshest of berries to flavor your pie.

  • Lakeshore Berry*
  • Lakeshore Crumb Berry*
  • Firehouse Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Holiday Hill Rhubarb
  • Good Harbor Raspberry
  • Leelanau Raspberry Apple Crumb
  • Splenda Blueberry
  • Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb
  • Mt. Berry Crumb
  • Blackberry

Buy Pies >

Cream Pies

  • Coconut
  • Banana
  • Chocolate
  • Peanut Butter
  • Mocha
  • Butterscotch

Key Lime

A taste of the tropics.

Awards

We’re proud that our pies have been recognized for their deliciousness!

  • Recognized in Country Living magazine as one of their top pies
  • Named one of the best online buys in Oprah Winfrey’s O Magazine
  • Featured on ABC’s Good Morning America!
  • Cherry Crumb Pie was first-ever “Signature Cherry Pie” of the National Cherry Festival
  • Featured on CNBC and The Food Network, the Cherry Crumb Pie was selected as “The Best of the Midwest” by Midwest Living Magazine
  • “I don’t think I’ve ever had as good a pie as Grand Traverse Pie Company’s Cherry Crumb Pie… It’s a religious experience.” — Mario Batali, The Food Network

Buy Pies >