Blueberry Lemon Silk Pie
Available for a limited time! Sweet Michigan blueberries topped with a light lemon whipped cream cheese filling made with freshly squeezed lemons, all decorated with a scalloped whipped cream topping, blueberries, and lemon zest. Check your shop for availability.
Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb
Our top selling pie made with tart Michigan Montmorency cherries, sweetened up with love and a toasty crumb topping. Our Cherry Crumb is the “Signature Pie” of the National Cherry Festival held in July in Traverse City every year!
Old Mission Cherry
Tasty Michigan Montmorency cherries fill this pie with a tangy deliciousness, all baked into our flaky crust. A scrumptious local northern Michigan favorite, named after one of the most beautiful peninsulas near Traverse City. Featured on Oprah Magazine’s “O List.”
Natural Michigan Cherry – No Sugar Added
Tasty Montmorency cherries sweetened with apple juice, fill GT Pie’s flaky crust with a tangy deliciousness.
Cherry Berry
A delicious blend of Michigan Montmorency cherries and juicy raspberries in our flaky crust. We recommend enjoying this pie near one of Northern Michigan’s many beautiful lakes.
Michigan ABC Crumb
Michigan Northern Spy apples, Michigan Rubel blueberries, Michigan Montmorency cherries – pure Michigan through and through. Finished with our toasty crumb topping.
Michigan ABC
Michigan Northern Spy apples, Michigan Rubel blueberries, Michigan Montmorency cherries baked in our flaky, homemade crust – the essence of pure Michigan.
Lighthouse Cherry Apple Crumb
This blend of Michigan Montmorency cherries and tree ripened Northern Spy apples is finished with our toasty crumb topping. A mouthwatering pie! Our shining light!
Cherry Peach Crumb
This pie is loaded with Michigan Montmorency cherries and sweet peaches, then finished with our amazing toasty crumb topping. A local favorite pie!
Cherry Rhubarb
The National Cherry Festival is a big event in our home town of Traverse City. When the local rhubarb is in season you might find us mixing our Michigan cherries with rhubarb for a special, seasonal treat.
Splenda Michigan Cherry
Sweetened with Splenda and filled with our Michigan Montmorency cherries. Sweets for all needs from GT Pie Co, splendid indeed.
Gluten Free Mini Cherry Crumb
This handmade pie starts with a gluten-free shortbread pie crust, into which we add a Michigan tart cherry filling and then top it off with our delicious crumb topping and sliced almonds. Also available in apple and chocolate cream.
Peninsula Apple Crumb
Named for our many peninsulas in Northern Michigan. Filled with Michigan-picked, sun-ripened Northern Spy apples that have been tossed with cinnamon and sugar, and finished with our toasty crumb topping.
Front Street Apple
Front Street is where our original shop first opened its doors! Michigan grown Northern Spy apples make this a good choice any time of year. Our homemade flaky pastry tops it off!
Apple Mountain Top Pie
Our classic Apple Pie on the inside and topped off with a hearty cinnamon oatmeal crumb topping.
Natural Michigan Apple – No Sugar Added
Filled with Michigan-picked, sun-ripened Northern Spy apples tossed with cinnamon and sweetened with apple juice then finished with our flaky pastry top.
Apple Crumb with Caramel and Pecans
We start with our Peninsula Apple Crumb pie, then we add toasted pecans and drizzle of caramel on top to make a finale that will tempt every taste bud! Perfect as a warm fall treat in honor of Northern Michigan’s cozy little towns.
Apple Dumpling with Caramel
This glorious pie reminds us of the Legend of Sleeping Bear, whose Dunes were voted the most beautiful place in the country by ABC News. Seven whole, cored Michigan apples are tossed in cinnamon & sugar, baked in our flaky crust and finished with a drizzle of caramel.
Splenda Michigan Apple
Sweetened with Splenda and featuring our Northern Spy Michigan apples, all made in our flaky pastry crust. Sweets for all needs from GT Pie Co., simply splendid.
Gluten Free Mini Apple Crumb
This handmade pie starts with a gluten-free shortbread pie crust, to which we add our Michigan Northern Spy apple filling with cinnamon, and perfected with our delicious crumb topping and sliced almonds. Its handmade taste is sure to thrill! Also available in cherry crumb.
Lakeshore Berry Crumb
Juicy berries picked at the height of the season – a mix of strawberries, raspberries, blackberries – and Michigan Spy apples with our toasty crumb topping. This pie pops with flavor and love from Michigan.
Lakeshore Berry
Brimming with juicy berries picked at the height of the season, this is our mix of strawberries, raspberries, blackberries and Michigan Spy apples with our flaky pastry top. From the shores of Michigan to you.
Mountain Berry Crumb
A blend of Michigan Rubel blueberries, raspberries, blackberries and ripe red strawberries in our flaky crust. Then our fabulous toasted crumb topping is embellished with oatmeal and brown sugar to make this pie extra flavorful. A warm slice of this pie will keep you toasty on any of Michigan’s slopes.
Blackberry
Rich, plump blackberries are stuffed into our flaky, pastry dough and topped with more of the same. This pie reminds us of canoe trips and finding blackberries along your travels.
Blackberry Peach Crumb
Sweet peaches and rich blackberries fill this pie, and then it’s finished with our toasty crumb topping. Every time you take a bite, think of the tall ships that cover Grand Traverse Bay all summer long.
West Bay Blueberry Crumb
This pie is bursting with summer-sweet, plump Michigan Rubel blueberries. The blues never tasted so good until they are finished with our toasty crumb topping. This pie tastes as good as the look of the rich blue waters of West Bay in Northern Michigan.
Suttons Bay Blueberry
Sweet, plump Michigan Rubel blueberries are featured in our flaky pastry crust. A classic which reminds us of the sweet summer atmosphere of Suttons Bay, Michigan.
Blueberry Peach
Mix plump Michigan Rubel blueberries with our sweet peaches together and we have a pie so happy we can hear it singing from the rafters of the Traverse City Opera House!
Splenda Michigan Blueberry
Sweetened with Splenda and featuring Michigan Rubel blueberries. Sweets for all needs from GT Pie Co., simply splendid.
Peach Crumb
A golden filling of luscious, tree-ripened peaches, brown sugar and vanilla. Baked to perfection finished with our toasty crumb topping. A wonderful pie to create memories of summer at your favorite Michigan beach.
Peach
Sweet peaches, brown sugar and vanilla baked to perfection with cinnamon and sugar sprinkled on top of our flaky crust sprinkled. Enjoy with a scoop of ice cream for a heavenly treat, biting into these crisp peaches will have you pining for summer farmer’s markets.
Peach Strawberry
Sweet peaches and ripe red strawberries in our flaky crust make this pie a perfect, mouth watering combination! This pie brings back memories of being in the heart of downtown Traverse City.
Raspberry
Think of rich summer sunsets at Good Harbor Beach. Plump red raspberries in a sweet filling and our flaky crust with a pastry topping. If you love raspberries this ones for you!
Raspberry Apple Crumb
The Leelanau Peninsula is a beautiful Up North Michigan treat and so is this pie! We blend plump red raspberries with Michigan Northern Spy apples and finish it with our toasty crumb topping.
Rhubarb
If you love rhubarb pie, you have to try ours. Tangy rhubarb, mixed with our sweet filling, all in our flaky crust makes for an amazing treat. A fresh taste reminiscent of brisk spring walks.
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb
Mixing the tart and the sweet with our toasted crumb topping makes this a sweetie pie to try. Nothing says summer like this classic combination.
Strawberry Rhubarb
It’s a marriage between sweetness and tartness as strawberries and rhubarb come together to form a most perfect pie. Handmade in our flaky pastry crust, this pie is in honor of the firefighters across the street from our original shop!
Banana Cream
This pie is built from the bottom up – we start with our flaky crust, add a layer of sliced bananas, a layer of our creamy vanilla filling and finish it off with a yummy whipped topping. What would a picnic be at the park without Banana Cream Pie?
Chocolate Cream
Made with fresh milk, butter and eggs like in the good ol’ days. Rich chocolate cream sits atop our flaky crust and then it’s finished with whipped topping and chocolate shavings. This pie pays homage to our amazing Old Town Traverse City.
Gluten Free Mini Chocolate Cream
This handmade pie starts with a gluten-free shortbread pie crust, to which we add a chocolate cream blend of semi-sweet and unsweetened chocolate, and finished with a delicious chocolate whip topping and chocolate shavings. Its handmade taste is sure to thrill!
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream
This popular combination requested often by Mike’s mom, Barb, starts with our flaky crust, topped with a layer of chocolate cream, followed by a layer of peanut butter cream. All finished with whipped topping and chocolate shavings. It’s like a Reese’s, but better!
Coconut Cream
Our delicious vanilla cream is full of coconut flakes, loaded into our flaky crust and finished with whipped topping and toasted coconut. It’s a tropical treasure!
Key Lime Pie
Made with real key lime juice, each pie’s cream tart filling is topped with fluffy, whipped topping rosettes and sits within a delicious graham cracker crust. The crystal blue waters of Petoskey make us feel like we have our own Key West!
Lemon Meringue
Made with real lemon juice and lemon zest, the tart filling is loaded into our delicious, flaky crust and topped with a mound of golden meringue. Pack your picnic basket with this pie as you travel the TART Trails of Traverse all the way up to Leelanau!
Pumpkin
This American classic features a pumpkin filling that reminds us of the cozy, quaint town of Northport. Country Living Magazine describes it to be “. . . a dense, mousse-like texture and a crust detail that won our hearts.”
Pecan
Our pecan pie is loaded with rich, gooey filling and mixed with an abundance of pecans, all baked in our flaky crust. Delicious! This pie will have you ready for a Northern Michigan fall!
Chocolate Pecan
A Northern version of a Southern classic. Handmade-from-scratch filling mixed with pecan halves and premium pieces of bittersweet chocolate chunks. Available for order year round all the way from Up North Michigan.
GT Pie Fusion Pie Series
Fusion Pies are bold, exciting and made with a powerful twist as we combine unique flavors (and often add a new Michigan ingredient!). Some past creations include: CEO Chocolate Stout, Strawberry Champagne and Jammin’ PB&J. Stay tuned for these and new fusion creations out of the GT Pie bakery!
